Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
Hi everyone.
First the specs of my tank: Size: 200lt (approx 50gal) 3ft tank Lighting: 6 x 30w T8 fluros of mixed color (5000k, 6500k, 10 000k) = 180W Filter: Eheim Professional 2224 CO2: Dupla system injecting through diffuser into filter Substrate: 2mm natural gravel with laterite in the bottom 1/4 Fertiliser: Water coloumn none so far, susbtrate Jobes deep under root feeders Fish: None Plants: Fast growing stem plants This tank has been setup for 3 weeks now (it has no fish) and was clear for about a week and now has a greenwater bloom in for about the past 2 weeks it so its definately out of balance. I have it heavily planted with fast growing stem species and during the day they are bubbling non stop. A few days ago I added some column fertiliser (pmdd) and some calcium chloride to buffer the water. These are the measurements I took this morning: pH: 6.2 kH: 2.8 or 50ppm gH: 90ppm CO2: 53ppm !!! Ooops I check the bubble counter and it was dosing at about 2 bubbles per second. I promptly turned it down a lil. My natural tapwater is: pH: 7.4 kH: 40ppm gH: 50ppm I just need some advice from you guys as what you would suggest to do to get rid of the greenwater and in general how I should go about dosing my tank. I have all the pmdd chemicals as well as flourish and flourish iron. I look foward to hearing your suggestions and dosing reigemes so I can get a better understanding on what I should be doing to keep the tank in balance. Cheers, Jon |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
2 Words -
UV STERALIZER I had the same thing foor 3 1/2 weeks - even with 3/4 water change twice a day for 3 days straight.. no help.. Added the steralizer... ran it for 3 days, did a 3/4 water change and im back to crystal clear water... plants are pearling more since the light can get to them now.. Dustin "J. H." wrote in message ... Hi everyone. First the specs of my tank: Size: 200lt (approx 50gal) 3ft tank Lighting: 6 x 30w T8 fluros of mixed color (5000k, 6500k, 10 000k) = 180W Filter: Eheim Professional 2224 CO2: Dupla system injecting through diffuser into filter Substrate: 2mm natural gravel with laterite in the bottom 1/4 Fertiliser: Water coloumn none so far, susbtrate Jobes deep under root feeders Fish: None Plants: Fast growing stem plants This tank has been setup for 3 weeks now (it has no fish) and was clear for about a week and now has a greenwater bloom in for about the past 2 weeks it so its definately out of balance. I have it heavily planted with fast growing stem species and during the day they are bubbling non stop. A few days ago I added some column fertiliser (pmdd) and some calcium chloride to buffer the water. These are the measurements I took this morning: pH: 6.2 kH: 2.8 or 50ppm gH: 90ppm CO2: 53ppm !!! Ooops I check the bubble counter and it was dosing at about 2 bubbles per second. I promptly turned it down a lil. My natural tapwater is: pH: 7.4 kH: 40ppm gH: 50ppm I just need some advice from you guys as what you would suggest to do to get rid of the greenwater and in general how I should go about dosing my tank. I have all the pmdd chemicals as well as flourish and flourish iron. I look foward to hearing your suggestions and dosing reigemes so I can get a better understanding on what I should be doing to keep the tank in balance. Cheers, Jon |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
I just need some advice from you guys as what you would suggest to do to
get rid of the greenwater and in general how I should go about dosing my tank. I have all the pmdd chemicals as well as flourish and flourish iron. Before investing on any equipments, Try adding 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon of KNO3 every other day and add 1/4 teaspoon of MgSO4 and 1/16 teaspoon of KH2PO4 every third day. 1/2 to 3/4 K2SO4 once a week. 5 to 10ml of flourish every other day. That is what I did on my 55 Gal. Now its crystal clear. -- Thank You Dominic http://www.dlink.org/aqua |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
Hi Dustin,
Thanks for the reply - are UV sterilisers really only a temporary solution ? Does the greenwater eventually come back ? Cheers Jon "DWS" wrote in message ... 2 Words - UV STERALIZER I had the same thing foor 3 1/2 weeks - even with 3/4 water change twice a day for 3 days straight.. no help.. Added the steralizer... ran it for 3 days, did a 3/4 water change and im back to crystal clear water... plants are pearling more since the light can get to them now.. Dustin "J. H." wrote in message ... Hi everyone. First the specs of my tank: Size: 200lt (approx 50gal) 3ft tank Lighting: 6 x 30w T8 fluros of mixed color (5000k, 6500k, 10 000k) = 180W Filter: Eheim Professional 2224 CO2: Dupla system injecting through diffuser into filter Substrate: 2mm natural gravel with laterite in the bottom 1/4 Fertiliser: Water coloumn none so far, susbtrate Jobes deep under root feeders Fish: None Plants: Fast growing stem plants This tank has been setup for 3 weeks now (it has no fish) and was clear for about a week and now has a greenwater bloom in for about the past 2 weeks it so its definately out of balance. I have it heavily planted with fast growing stem species and during the day they are bubbling non stop. A few days ago I added some column fertiliser (pmdd) and some calcium chloride to buffer the water. These are the measurements I took this morning: pH: 6.2 kH: 2.8 or 50ppm gH: 90ppm CO2: 53ppm !!! Ooops I check the bubble counter and it was dosing at about 2 bubbles per second. I promptly turned it down a lil. My natural tapwater is: pH: 7.4 kH: 40ppm gH: 50ppm I just need some advice from you guys as what you would suggest to do to get rid of the greenwater and in general how I should go about dosing my tank. I have all the pmdd chemicals as well as flourish and flourish iron. I look foward to hearing your suggestions and dosing reigemes so I can get a better understanding on what I should be doing to keep the tank in balance. Cheers, Jon |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
Thanks for the suggestion Dominic.. I think this may be a more viable
solution to solving the problem. Are these amounts from calculations or just pure observation of what worked for you ? Cheers Jon "Aqua" wrote in message ... I just need some advice from you guys as what you would suggest to do to get rid of the greenwater and in general how I should go about dosing my tank. I have all the pmdd chemicals as well as flourish and flourish iron. Before investing on any equipments, Try adding 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon of KNO3 every other day and add 1/4 teaspoon of MgSO4 and 1/16 teaspoon of KH2PO4 every third day. 1/2 to 3/4 K2SO4 once a week. 5 to 10ml of flourish every other day. That is what I did on my 55 Gal. Now its crystal clear. -- Thank You Dominic http://www.dlink.org/aqua |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
Thanks for the suggestion Dominic.. I think this may be a more viable
solution to solving the problem. Are these amounts from calculations or just pure observation of what worked for you ? This is from Tom's Estimative Index. I do not have a link to that article. Search this group or fins.actwin.com/aquatic-plants for more information on that. Also my water parameters are almost similar to yours. -- Thank You Dominic http://www.dlink.org/aqua |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
Jon,
I just went through the same thing you did about 6 months ago. I set up a 46 gallon tank with high light. Here is my tank discription: 46 gallon (174 liter) 2 compact flourecent bulbs, 98 watts each DIY CO2 at about 20ppm Seachem Flourish, 1mL every other day 4 moderate size goldfish (Comets) Ehimen ProII 2026 Substrate is gavel of varing sizes Bottom half of substrate is 2-3mm gavel with laterite Medium planted As I said, I went through the same greeen water that you went through. I think it is pretty common, and espically so with beginners with high light tanks. There are ways to avoid it when setting up a tank, but you may not be willing to start over. I purchased a UV sterilizer. It worked pretty well, although it took about a week to clear up. I think I had a pretty large bloom because I got a 25W sterilizer which is quite large for 46 gallons. With regards to your question about green water coming back, it usually doesn't. At least it hasn't with me. I think once a tank has cycled it is less like to have green water. I would recommend cutting back on the lights until the tank cycles for a while. The lights that I have have an independent switch for each bulb, this makes it easy to reduce the wattage over the tank. I agree with what others have posted, which is your tank is out of balance. High light tanks require special attention, more of it. You'll need to measure your phosphates, nitrates, ammonia, nitrites until your tank becomes more stable. Search the web and read some of the older postings here, there is a lot to learn to balance a tank with high light. Keep at it, high light tanks can be an adventure. Later, Tony |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
I purchased a UV sterilizer. It worked pretty well, although it took
about a week to clear up. I think I had a pretty large bloom because I got a 25W sterilizer which is quite large for 46 gallons. It might clear up faster if you use a flocculant. Something like Mardel's Brite N Clear, that causes particles to clump together so they can be removed by the filter. IME, the combination of UV sterilizer + flocculant can clear greenwater over night. Leigh http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/ |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
Thanks for the reply Tony.
I thought I set the tank up properly for no algae problems I heavily planted the whole bottom with fast growin stem species from my previous planted tank and they are growing like crazy. I have pressurised CO2 keeping the levels high and high light. On others reccomendations I was not going to dose any nutrients till week 3 or 4 but the greenwater still happened. I have no fishload in the tank at all at the moment and have been trying Dominics methods but its just getting greener.. currently in the process of dumping 3/4 of the water Cheers Jon "Tony" wrote in message om... Jon, I just went through the same thing you did about 6 months ago. I set up a 46 gallon tank with high light. Here is my tank discription: 46 gallon (174 liter) 2 compact flourecent bulbs, 98 watts each DIY CO2 at about 20ppm Seachem Flourish, 1mL every other day 4 moderate size goldfish (Comets) Ehimen ProII 2026 Substrate is gavel of varing sizes Bottom half of substrate is 2-3mm gavel with laterite Medium planted As I said, I went through the same greeen water that you went through. I think it is pretty common, and espically so with beginners with high light tanks. There are ways to avoid it when setting up a tank, but you may not be willing to start over. I purchased a UV sterilizer. It worked pretty well, although it took about a week to clear up. I think I had a pretty large bloom because I got a 25W sterilizer which is quite large for 46 gallons. With regards to your question about green water coming back, it usually doesn't. At least it hasn't with me. I think once a tank has cycled it is less like to have green water. I would recommend cutting back on the lights until the tank cycles for a while. The lights that I have have an independent switch for each bulb, this makes it easy to reduce the wattage over the tank. I agree with what others have posted, which is your tank is out of balance. High light tanks require special attention, more of it. You'll need to measure your phosphates, nitrates, ammonia, nitrites until your tank becomes more stable. Search the web and read some of the older postings here, there is a lot to learn to balance a tank with high light. Keep at it, high light tanks can be an adventure. Later, Tony |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
It might clear up faster if you use a flocculant. Something like Mardel's
Brite N Clear, that causes particles to clump together so they can be removed by the filter. IME, the combination of UV sterilizer + flocculant can clear greenwater over night. Leigh, I think I'm a bit confused, what is focculant? A flocculant is something makes small particles clump together into bigger particles. There are several brands on the market. I usually use Mardel Lab's "Brite N Clear." Flocculants help clear the water, because large particles are more easily removed by your filter. Leigh http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/ |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
I think I'm a bit confused, what is focculant? also called floss... filter floss... looks like a mile of dental floss all wrapped up in a handful sized ball, mat, or section.... |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
I think I'm a bit confused, what is focculant?
also called floss... filter floss... looks like a mile of dental floss all wrapped up in a handful sized ball, mat, or section.... No, that's not what I was talking about. I was talking about chemicals like Brite N Clear. Usually liquid. You add them to your tank to clear the water. They work by causing fine particles to clump together, so your filter can remove them. Leigh http://www.fortunecity.com/lavender/halloween/881/ |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
"J. H." wrote in message ...
Thanks for the reply Tony. I thought I set the tank up properly for no algae problems I heavily planted the whole bottom with fast growin stem species from my previous planted tank and they are growing like crazy. I have pressurised CO2 keeping the levels high and high light. On others reccomendations I was not going to dose any nutrients till week 3 or 4 but the greenwater still happened. I have no fishload in the tank at all at the moment and have been trying Dominics methods but its just getting greener.. currently in the process of dumping 3/4 of the water Cheers Jon Jon, I'm not sure that I can be of much help. It would be interesting to see if you could clear it up without a UV sterilizer. It sounds like you've done some research before getting started. The only think I can recommend is cutting back on the lights and working up to higher wattage. You may not be able to do that. Also at this point, cutting back on lights may not help in the long run. Have you checked your phospates, nitrites, nitrates and iron? It could be that when you added water you stirred up the substrate enough to suspend material that is causing the algae bloom. I got one because of two reasons. One, to clear the green water. I figured with almost 200 watts over 46 gallons it would difficult to clear the green water. Two, because I thought it would help prevent diseases. I intended to use it when I added new plants or fish to the tank to help clear any floating bacteria or algae that might have gotten in. I'm not clear that this would help significantly. I'm not using mine now, but I'm thinking of creating a secondary filtration system and including the UV sterilzer on that. I'd like to be able to suck up crud on the bottom of the tank without having to do a water change. I figure I could get a pump and a some kind of mechanical filter. I could also just leave this second system running when I add new fish/plants to the tank, it won't hurt anything. |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help
On Thu, 27 Mar 2003 22:02:25 -0800, "DWS" wrote:
Sure a UV will work. But you are treating the symptom and not the problem. 2 Words - UV STERALIZER I had the same thing foor 3 1/2 weeks - even with 3/4 water change twice a day for 3 days straight.. no help.. Added the steralizer... ran it for 3 days, did a 3/4 water change and im back to crystal clear water... plants are pearling more since the light can get to them now.. Dustin Semper Fi! Visit the forums at Aqua Botanic! http://aquabotanicwetthumb.infopop.cc/#1 Need Nitrate or Potassium for your tank? Go to www.litemanu.com (Just a happy customer of the above!) |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Balance between nutrients, light & CO2 | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( help | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
help with high light/high co2 tank out of balance = greenwater :( | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
greenwater | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
greenwater | Freshwater Aquaria Plants |